56 Plymouth Ave, Maplewood – SOLD!
Welcome home to 56 Plymouth Ave, Maplewood. Located on an idyllic tree-lined street, this renovated Colonial is less than a mile from the village shops, restaurants and MidTown Direct train to Penn Station.
It’s easy to imagine yourself living in this home: The kitchen was beautifully renovated in 2020 with an eye on modern day functionality – loads of storage, a deep sink overlooking the yard, exposed wood shelves, and stainless steel appliances. The center island with built-in microwave, storage and additional seating elevates every day life. The large living room with fireplace connects to the bonus sunroom overlooking the backyard, perfect as a play space or private home office. A charming first floor powder room finishes off the first floor.
Upstairs you’ll find three generously sized bedrooms, each with double exposure for plenty of natural light, and a handsomely renovated full bathroom with tub. The primary bedroom features a walk-in closet smartly hidden behind a sliding barn door. The unfinished attic provides additional storage.
The basement is unfinished yet boasts surprisingly high ceilings, full waterproofing, and utilities along the perimeter making the task of finishing it an easy and obvious win. A newer roof (2020), upgraded electrical panel (2020), new first floor HVAC (2020), newer boiler (2021) and water heater (2023) provide peace of mind.
56 Plymouth of Improvements
2025
- Repainted the exterior of the house
- Replaced the driveway
2023
- Replaced water heater in
- French drains and sump pump installed
2021
- Replaced boiler
2020
-
Replaced downstairs HVAC
-
New roof
-
Repainted the entire house and replaced trim
-
Replaced windows in the kitchen by the sink, upstairs bathroom, and guest bedroom at the rear of the house
-
Refinished all wood floors
-
Refinished the sunroom
-
All new appliances
-
Full kitchen remodel
-
Full bathroom remodel
-
Upgraded electrical panel
Dear Future Homeowner,
There’s something magical about turning a key and stepping into a place that instantly feels like home. That’s the feeling that has greeted us over the last five years at 56 Plymouth Avenue. Nestled on a quiet, tree-lined street where neighbors still wave hello or stop for a quick chat, our home has been the backdrop to countless cherished memories.
Over the last five years, we thoughtfully updated many of the appliances and fixtures throughout the home, bringing modern efficiency to every room while maintaining its charm and inviting atmosphere. The renovated kitchen has been the true heart of our home and central gathering place for countless events with family and friends. The huge kitchen island has been perfect for both preparing holiday meals as well as eating weeknight dinners with the family.
Beyond our doorstep, the vibrant community of Maplewood has embraced us with its charming downtown, excellent schools, and the best neighbors you could ask for. We’ve treasured the convenience of being just steps away from the incredible local coffee shops (The Able Baker and The Bread Stand are our favorites!) and the nearby parks and playgrounds where we’ve spent countless hours with our kids. Just a short distance to the Maplewood Train Station, you’ll enjoy the perfect balance of small-town comfort with big-city access.
As we prepare to pass our beloved home to its next caretakers, we hope you’ll feel that same sense of homecoming that we’ve cherished all these years. The memories we’ve made here will move with us, but the warmth, character, and heart of 56 Plymouth Avenue remains—waiting for you to write the next chapter.
Welcome home,
The O’Sullivans
Aidan, Melissa, Rory (4), Olivia (4) and Callum (9 Months)
Call or email us to schedule a private showing!
tandemnj@compass.com or (973) 991-9954
